Image by Tanarch on Canva
Two prominent destinations stand out regarding property investment in Southeast Asia: Bali, Indonesia, and Phuket, Thailand. Each location offers a unique blend of cultural richness, investment opportunities, and lifestyle benefits that appeal to foreign investors. Understanding the nuances of each market is crucial for making informed decisions. This comparison will explore various aspects of investing in Bali and Phuket, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses and ultimately suggesting why Bali may be a more favorable option for investors.
Property Ownership and Legal Framework
One of the most significant considerations for foreign investors is property ownership and the legal frameworks governing it.
Due to Indonesian law, foreign investors cannot directly own land in Bali. However, they have several options for acquiring property. The most common route is through leasehold agreements, which typically last for 30 years and can often be extended. Additionally, foreigners can establish a PT PMA (Penanaman Modal Asing), a foreign-owned company, which allows them to hold freehold ownership of property(InvestinAsia). This flexibility in ownership structures is particularly appealing for long-term investments in Bali’s burgeoning real estate market.
Phuket, on the other hand, offers a different set of challenges. Foreigners can purchase property, but they are restricted from owning land outright. Instead, they must establish a Thai company or enter into long-term leases, typically lasting up to 30 years, with an option to renew(Bali.RealEstate). While the legal processes in Phuket are manageable, the requirement for establishing a company can be a barrier for some investors, complicating the investment landscape.
Tax Obligations
Understanding tax obligations is critical for foreign investors as they can significantly impact profitability.
In Bali, the tax system is relatively straightforward. Essential taxes include the Land and Building Tax (PBB), which is relatively low, as well as the Property Transfer Tax and Value Added Tax (PPN), currently set at 11% for properties sold by professional developers (InvestinAsia). The low tax rates make Bali an attractive option for investors looking to maximize their returns.
In Phuket, the tax obligations are more complex. The Property Transfer Tax is set at 2%, and if the property is sold within five years of acquisition, a Specific Business Tax (SBT) of 3.3% applies(Bali.RealEstate). These additional taxes can erode profits and complicate financial forecasting for investors. The comparative simplicity of Bali's tax landscape could be a decisive factor for foreign buyers.
Market Growth Potential
Bali and Phuket have experienced growth in their real estate markets, but the trajectory and potential differ significantly.
Bali has seen a remarkable resurgence in its property market following the lifting of COVID-19 travel restrictions, drawing considerable foreign interest in vacation rentals and residential properties (InvestinAsia). The island’s tourism-driven economy contributes to ongoing demand, enhancing property values and rental yields. Bali's strategic focus on attracting international visitors—through wellness tourism, cultural experiences, and eco-friendly initiatives—positions it for continued growth in the coming years.
While still a popular tourist destination, Phuket has shown signs of market saturation, leading to slower growth rates than Bali(Bali.RealEstate)(Lazudi). The island’s reliance on mass tourism may pose challenges as competition increases, and investors could find it harder to achieve high returns in a crowded market.
Which one is better?
Bali and Phuket offer appealing property investment opportunities, each with unique advantages. Bali provides a flexible legal framework for foreign investors, allowing long-term leasehold agreements and the option to establish a PT PMA for freehold ownership; this flexibility can enhance investors' security.
While Phuket has charm and established infrastructure, Bali’s tax structure is generally more favorable, with lower property taxes than Phuket. Bali’s real estate market is also experiencing notable growth, driven by a resurgence in tourism after COVID-19. The island’s vibrant culture, stunning landscapes, and focus on wellness tourism make it a compelling destination for living and investing, catering to diverse preferences and lifestyles.
In summary, both locations have their merits, but Bali's unique blend of legal options, tax advantages, and lifestyle appeal make it a noteworthy consideration for property investors in Southeast Asia.
Where to Invest in Bali?
The real estate market in Bali offers a wide selection of properties, from luxury villas to minimalist studios or apartments. As one of the leading property agencies in Bali, we recommend you invest in Canggu, Seminyak, and Uluwatu. These locations are home to 5-star hotels and world-class beach clubs.
Canggu's pristine beaches are perfect for surfing, and its vibrant lifestyle makes it a hotspot for property investment in Bali. There are many selections of unique restaurants, high-end boutiques, world-class beach clubs, and international schools.
Furthermore, Uluwatu offers breathtaking views of the Indian Ocean's stunning coastline and is home to the majestic Garuda Wisnu Kencana statue. Additionally, Uluwatu is an excellent place to surf, as its beaches provide perfect waves for beginner and expert surfers.
Seminyak is a place for those who seek an upscale lifestyle. Its location offers beautiful beaches, a restless nightlife, and a wide range of delicate dining areas.
In addition, Seseh, Cemagi, and Pererenan are experiencing rapid growth in property development, making them ample locations for investment. Bali is renowned for its stunning natural landscapes, vibrant expat communities, and rich cultural heritage.
When considering real estate investment, Bali stands out with its expanding villa market and booming tourism sector. These make it an attractive option for those looking to achieve robust rental returns.
While Bali and Phuket present significant opportunities for property appreciation, Bali's unique blend of culture and natural beauty solidifies its position as a top choice for Southeast Asian investors.
So, have you secured your dream property in Bali? Take a look at our property collection and book a consultation with us.
